Monday, October 31, 2005

Poverty


"Just as Hurricane Katrina destroyed lives and communities, it also demolished the illusion that the challenges facing poor families and neighborhoods are “somebody else’s” problems. ... many Americans may recognize a new reality: poverty must be our entire nation’s concern. Some may even understand in a new way that their own hometowns face similar challenges ..." -- F Barton Harvey of the Enterprise Foundation


We're too used to being able to ignore poverty because it was only something that occurred in other countries. We see people starving in Africa, but only in the abstract. It doesn't affect our daily lives. But when Katrina came, the scenes we saw on our television looked like they could have been Somalia.

Poverty isn't something that's happened over night. So, you can't blame it on one administration. But some administrations are better than others at addressing it. The media largely ignores the problem. When they do say something, it's misleading. For example, famous tool Bill O'Reilly said, "... halfway through President Clinton's tenure in office in 1996, the poverty rate was 13.7 percent. Halfway through President Bush's tenure, the rate is 12.7 percent, a full point lower". Technically correct but misleading. As David Brock of Media Matters shows, "During the Clinton presidency, the poverty rate fell from 15.1 percent in 1993 to a low of 11.3 percent in 2000; it has risen every year that Bush has been in office, from 11.7 percent in 2001 to 12.7 percent in 2004." So, while the mid-term averages would lead you to believe that Bush was doing more than Clinton did, the truth is exactly the opposite. Clinton took office with a high rate given to him by the elder Bush and successfully lowered by almost 4 percentage points. Bush, given a lower poverty rate, does the exact opposite. For more info: Media Matters

"Unfortunately, many Americans live on the outskirts of hope, some because of their poverty, and some because of their color, and all too many because of both. This administration declares unconditional war on poverty in America." -- Lyndon Johnson


You wonder why Kanye West says that the President doesn't care about black people and then you hear him say, ,"I was disappointed, frankly, in the vote I got in the African-American community. I was. I’ve done my best to elevate people to positions of authority and responsibility — not just positions, but positions where they can actually make a difference in the lives of people. I put people in my Cabinet. I put people in my sub-Cabinet.". He sounds more concerned with getting votes than with helping anyone.

US poverty: chronic ill, little hope for cure

Here are the facts:

  • Since 2000, the ranks of the poor have increased year by year by almost 5.5 million in total
  • Today, 33% of black children live in families under the poverty level.
  • Last year, African American households had the lowest median income of any racial group ($30134), down a full percentage point from the year before.
  • The unemployment rate for African-Americans is double the rate for white Americans. Over the past six months, the average unemployment rate for white Americans was 4.39 percent; for black Americans, it was 10.06 percent.
  • Poverty is a universal problem, as is inequality. The world's 500 richest people, according to U.N. statistics, have as much income as the world's poorest 416 million.

    Statistics and quote from: Think Progress

"The federal government declared war on poverty, and poverty won." -- Ronald Reagan in 1988


What can we do?

Raise the minimum wage -- From Think Progress:

  • 4.3 million: Number of Americans who have fallen into poverty since President Bush took office
  • $5.15: Federal minimum wage
  • $5,000: Amount below the poverty level working 40 hours a week, 52 weeks a year at minimum wage will leave a family of three
  • 7,300,000: Number of workers who would benefit from an increase in the minimum wage
  • 72%: Percentage of adult workers who would benefit from an increase in the minimum wage
  • 1,800,000: Number of parents with kids under the age of 18 who would benefit from an increase in the minimum wage
  • 11 million: Number of jobs added to the economy in the four years after the last minimum wage hike
  • 2.5 years: Amount of health care for two children which could be bought by raising the minimum wage from $5.15 to $7.25
  • 86%: Percentage of Americans who support raising the federal minimum wage

Mr. Harvey of the Enterprise Foundation in his paper, Ending Concentrated Poverty, goes into some of the causes of US poverty:

What has caused concentrated poverty:

  • deindustrialization
  • globalization
  • suburban development that does not included poor and minority families

The above have all eroded the job base in the heart of cities. But he has several workable, proven solutions:

  • enhance access to opportunity for low-income families
    - housing choice vouchers to help with rent in communities they choose or to help with mortgages
  • rebuild and reinvest in a smart, sustainable way
    - "private-public partnerships to turn dysfunctional environments into healthier communities"
  • ensure meaningful decision-making roles for low-income people

We cannot be considered a civilized society if we continue to leave a larger and larger segment of our population behind. We talk about being proud to be an American because fight wars in foreign lands. We need to be proud to be an American because we're fighting a war here ... against racism and poverty.

15 comments:

Laura said...

The cynical side of me thinks that America will never solve the poverty problem. There are far too many people that buy into the selfish, rampant individualism of every man for himself and total unregulated accumulation of capital. The American Dream is built on the sweat and graves of the poor, and for that reason, is a total lie.

I see homeless people on the street every single day in the Loop and it pains me to walk by. I don't give out change because I have seen many of the panhandlers in 7-11 using that money to buy liquor. But I do try to give to shelters, give away clothes, food, etc. I'll buy the guy standing outside dunkin donuts a coffee and a muffin. But there's only so much I can do.

How do we get the millions of Americans wrapped up in their own lives to care?

dbackdad said...

It's not just the homeless. It's the working poor. Somehow, we need to make it that everyone that is working full-time is actually making enough to live somewhere and to feed their family.

We do the same as you. We give money and volunteer at our local food bank.

Bringing pressure on our legislators to increase the minimum wage and increase health-care coverage for the working poor are other things we can do. There is a large segment of the population that makes too much to get health-care assistance but not enough to afford their own insurance.

CyberKitten said...

We're lucky having a National Health Service here. It gets a lot of flack for various things but at least we don't have to pay for it if we're ill.

Laura said...

But socialized health care goes against the very principle of the American ideal of private ownership and the wonders of the free market.

I really wish people would wake up to the fact that no one is truly free in this country when we all answer to the upper 1%.

dbackdad said...

Laura,

You hit the nail on the head. The free market is the cure for all ills ... or so they would have us believe. That's the easiest way for them to scare people off of something: accuse it of being socialistic or communist.

CyberKitten said...

We have the 'Spectre' of the Nanny State here - pretty much the same thing though....

As if the 'Free Market' can actually deal with a lot of societies ills....

The Mixed Economy seems to be the best way of getting things done - of course the difficult bit is getting the mix right...

greatwhitebear said...

Unfortunaely, Katrina changed America about the same way 9/11 did. Only it took even less time for things to get back to normal.

Too many people profit off of the poor for anyone to take overcoming poverty seriously

CyberKitten said...

greatwhitebear said: Too many people profit off of the poor for anyone to take overcoming poverty seriously

I guess that's why revolutions happen from time to time.....

Anyone remember 1789 in a little place called Paris....?

Laura said...

Cyberkitten: You assume your average American remembers history? Especially from a country we're boycotting and is run by Satan ;)

CyberKitten said...

Laura said: Cyberkitten: You assume your average American remembers history? Especially from a country we're boycotting and is run by Satan ;)

True... and of course knowledge of history (and foreign political history at that) is probably discouraged....

"Those who do not remember (their) history are doomed to repeat it"..

Or words to that effect... Anyway - revolutions normally originate in the Middles Classes and not with the Workers....

greatwhitebear said...

As the official Guillotine operator for teh revolution, I can tell you that at least one american knows his history. Heads will roll!

CyberKitten said...

greatwhitebear said: As the official Guillotine operator for the revolution, I can tell you that at least one american knows his history. Heads will roll!


..and the Revolution WILL be televised. I look forward to watching it on the nightly news..

greatwhitebear said...

ck - just remember, those who don't participate in the revolution are the enemies of the revolution...

CyberKitten said...

GBW said: ck - just remember, those who don't participate in the revolution are the enemies of the revolution...

Then you'll have to give me a bit of advanced warning so I can book a flight across 'The Pond'

CyberKitten said...

That's GWB said.....